Cooling Tower Water Pump - Cracked
Inner Race
Case History Number 15
P502D pump forms part of a team of
4 identical units responsible for supplying the production unit with cooling water.
Depending on the time of year and thus the amount of cooling water required by the
production unit, determines how many of the 4 pumps will be in service at any one time.
Overall and spectral vibration data collected from the electric motor and pump bearings on
P502D over the last 4 years had been consistently low and acceptable, with levels
typically being around 1.5 to 2.5 mm/s rms.
This particular pump had been out of service for inspection purposes and had not been
tested for several weeks. During the routine vibration survey on the 21st
January 1998 it was noticed that the overall vibration levels recorded at the pump drive
end had exhibited a marked increase see, Figure 1.

Figure 1 - Pump drive end
bearing trend.
Examination
of the vibration spectrum exhibited frequency components which matched the calculated
defect frequencies for an RHP 318 C3 roller bearing with a inner race speed of 740 rpm,
this defect frequency was calculated to be 192.5 Hz see Figure 2.

Figure 2 - Vibration
spectrum indicating bearing inner race defect.
On further examination of this
vibration spectrum, not only were the bearing inner race defect frequency components
evident, but also across the frequency bandwidth was a large degree of sub synchronous
vibration, possibly caused by the rolling elements passing over the tiny particles of
metal from the original fault that had been impregnated into the surface of the inner and
outer races.
A recommendation was made to replace the pump bearing and pass it to our office for
inspection. Figure 3 below is photographic evidence of this inspection and indicates a
crack all the way across and through the inner race leaving one part protruding slightly
higher than the other. This slight protrusion would undoubtedly be the mechanism for
generating the inner race spectral frequency component as the rolling elements passed over
it.

Figure 3 - Photograph showing
crack through the inner race.
Further examination of the rollers
and bearing races indicated surface irregularities in the form of indentations caused by
tiny fragments of bearing material being forced into the raceways by the action of the
rolling elements passing over them and it is these irregularities which would be
responsible for the sub-synchronous vibration which was observed in the spectrum.
Fortunately the bearing inner ring did not spin on the pump shaft and therefore secondary
damage was minimised allowing bearing replacement to be carried out in situ.
The pump was subsequently brought back into service with minimal disruption to the
process, baseline vibration recorded at the pump bearings indicated levels had returned to
previous values. The estimated mechanical cost saving for this machine was in the region
of £12,000.

-::- This site is designed and
authored by David Stevens IEng
MIET FIDiagE
MICML
-::-
Copyright © |